Joanne Young Urges Law Change After Rape Verdict
Joanne Young, drugged and raped by her husband and strangers he invited online, waived anonymity after four men were convicted. She and her daughter now call for a legal change on consent, drawing comparisons to Gisèle Pelicot.
Joanne Young, drugged and raped by her husband and strangers he invited online, waived her anonymity after four men were convicted at Winchester Crown Court. She and her daughter are now calling for a legal change to clarify that third-party consent is not a valid defence, drawing comparisons to the Gisèle Pelicot case in France.
-
The abuse spanned 13 years and involved multiple online platforms
Philip Young, 50, drugged and abused his wife over a 13-year period at their home in Swindon, Wiltshire. He used websites such as Craigslist, Grindr and FabSwingers to advertise her for sex, portraying the abuse as a shared sexual kink known as 'cuckolding'. The photographs used in the adverts showed Joanne inanimate and tied to the bed. [2] [3]
-
Defendants claimed they believed they had consent from both partners
The four convicted men—Norman Macksoni, 48, Richard Wilkins, 62, Connor Sanderson-Doyle, 32, and Mohammed Hassan, 38—told the court they believed they had the consent of both Joanne and Philip Young and were told Joanne was pretending to be asleep, when in fact she was heavily sedated. Specialist prosecutor James Foster noted that not once during the abuse did they ask Joanne Young what she wanted or show any interest in her wishes. [2]
-
The law on consent does not explicitly bar third-party consent as a defence
The Sexual Offences Act 2003 states that a person consents if they agree by choice and have the freedom and capacity to make that choice. Criminal barrister Kate Parker explained that legally, a third party cannot consent on a person's behalf, but the defence used by the four men—that they relied on Philip Young's word—is not a correct application of the law and may be used in mitigation for sentencing. [3]
-
National Crime Agency has identified over 270 individuals linked to similar online forums
The National Crime Agency said there was an 'urgent need' to deal with the problem as an international issue, with investigators identifying more than 270 individuals linked to one online forum and successor groups. Professor Marianne Hester noted that investigations have started on certain websites and that individuals have been identified in a number of different countries engaged in the same kind of offending. [2]
-
Women's rights advocates and politicians call for online safety law updates
Jess Phillips, former minister for safeguarding and violence against women and girls, suggested online safety laws should be updated to prevent these cases. Farah Nazeer, chief executive of Women's Aid, praised Joanne Young's bravery, stating that chemical coercion is a horrific crime that leaves women questioning their own sense of reality. The Labour peer Thangam Debbonaire called her statement outside court 'extraordinary'. [4]